Does Liability Insurance Cover Theft?

Liability insurance is one of the most commonly misunderstood types of coverage—especially when it comes to theft. If your car, equipment, or even a catalytic converter is stolen, will liability insurance help you recover the loss? The short answer: No. Liability insurance does not cover theft. But there’s a lot more to understand if you want to be fully protected.

In this guide, we break down what liability insurance really covers, explore different theft-related scenarios, and show you exactly what kind of insurance you need for theft protection. We also compare types of policies, debunk myths, and walk you through what to do if your car or business equipment is stolen.

Key Takeaways: Does Liability Insurance Cover Theft?

• Liability insurance does not cover theft—it only pays for damage or injuries you cause to others.

• To protect your vehicle from theft, you need comprehensive coverage.

• If you’re a business owner, protect work equipment with inland marine, commercial property, or crime insurance.

• Common theft scenarios like stolen catalytic converters or tools from a work van are not covered under liability.

• Many people believe liability covers theft—it doesn’t. This is one of the most common insurance myths.

• If your car is stolen and you only have liability, you’re responsible for the full loss.

• The most complete theft protection plan includes:

  • Comprehensive auto insurance

  • Business Owners Policy (BOP)

  • Employee dishonesty or crime insurance (if applicable)

What Does Liability Insurance Actually Cover?

Liability insurance covers damage or injuries you cause to others. There are two main types:

• Bodily Injury Liability: Covers medical bills and legal costs if you injure someone in an accident.
• Property Damage Liability: Covers repairs to someone else’s vehicle or property.

It does NOT cover:

• Your own vehicle
• Theft or vandalism
• Fire or weather damage

The Right Insurance for Theft: What You Really Need

To be protected against theft, you’ll need comprehensive coverage. This type of policy protects your vehicle or insured asset against:

• Theft
• Vandalism
• Natural disasters
• Falling objects (like tree limbs)
• Fire and floods

If your car is stolen and you only have liability coverage, you’ll be responsible for the loss entirely.

Theft Scenarios and What Insurance You Need

Liability Insurance Myths – Busted

Myth #1: Liability covers all car-related issues

Truth: It only covers damage you cause to others. Nothing else.

Myth #2: You can add theft to liability coverage

Truth: Theft coverage requires comprehensive, which is separate.

Myth #3: General liability covers stolen property in your business

Truth: General liability protects against lawsuits and third-party injuries—not property theft.

Personal vs. Business Theft Coverage

If you’re a small business owner, the theft risks multiply. Here’s what to consider:

• General Liability Insurance: Covers bodily injury and property damage to third parties. No theft protection.
• Business Owners Policy (BOP): Combines general liability with commercial property coverage. This can include theft.
• Commercial Auto Insurance: If equipment is stolen from your work van, you need inland marine or tools and equipment coverage.

Pro Tip: If your business has employees, consider Employee Dishonesty or Crime Insurance to protect against internal theft.

What If Your Car Is Stolen With Only Liability Coverage?

If you only have liability insurance and your car is stolen:

1. You can’t file a claim. Liability doesn’t cover your loss.
2. You’ll need to contact the police and file a report.
3. You’ll absorb the financial hit unless you had comprehensive coverage.

What to Do If Your Car or Equipment Is Stolen

1. Call the police immediately.
2. Contact your insurance provider (even if it’s liability-only, for documentation).
3. Provide your VIN and any other evidence (surveillance footage, GPS, etc.).
4. Track your credit if your wallet or identity documents were in the vehicle.
5. Review your policy to ensure better coverage going forward.

Comparing Liability vs. Comprehensive vs. Collision

FAQs About Theft and Liability Insurance

Q: Is theft covered by general liability insurance?
A: No, general liability covers injuries or damages to others—not theft.

Q: Which insurance protects against theft?
A: Comprehensive auto insurance, commercial property insurance, and crime insurance depending on the asset.

Q: Does insurance pay out for a stolen vehicle?
A: Only if you have comprehensive coverage. Liability alone will not pay.

Q: Are you liable for a stolen car?
A: Generally, no—unless you left it running with keys inside or were negligent.

Conclusion: The Theft-Proof Policy Plan

If theft protection is important to you, liability insurance isn’t enough. It’s vital, yes—but only to meet legal requirements and cover others in an accident. To protect your car, business tools, or equipment from theft, you need to explore:

• Comprehensive auto coverage
• Business property insurance
• Crime or employee dishonesty coverage

References and Resources

🔐 Theft Protection & Coverage

• Inland Marine Insurance
  Protects business property in transit, such as tools and equipment in work vehicles.
  Learn more​

• Commercial Property Insurance
  Covers physical assets from risks like fire, theft, and storms.
  Explore coverage​

• Commercial Auto Insurance
  Provides financial security in the event of vehicle accidents or theft.
  Find out more​

🛡️ Business Liability & Risk Management

• General Liability Insurance
  Helps protect against lawsuits claiming your company caused injuries or property damage.
  Discover details​

• Business Liability Risks Checklist
  Assess potential coverage gaps in your current policies.
  Review the checklist​

💼 Employee & Crime Coverage

• Cyber Insurance: Coverage, Costs, Pros and Cons
  Understand how cyber insurance can protect against data breaches and cyber threats.
  Read the article​

• Daycare Liability Insurance
  Highlights the importance of separate coverage for employee dishonesty.
  Learn more​

🚗 Auto & Vehicle Insurance

• Auto Insurance for Young Drivers
  Discusses comprehensive coverage options and discounts for young drivers.
  Explore options​

• Is GAP Insurance Worth It?
  Evaluates the benefits of GAP insurance in covering the difference between a car’s value and loan balance.
  Read more

Don’t just insure for legality—insure for reality. Fill out the form below to contact us today!