Hotaling Insurance Services Logo

Classic Car Insurance Services Near Melville

Safeguarding Your Timeless Treasure: Classic Car Insurance in Long Island, Melville, NY

Table of Contents

Safeguarding Your Timeless Treasure: Classic Car Insurance Long Island


In the scenic locales of Long Island, NY, classic cars are not just modes of transportation; they’re cherished symbols of history and passion. Protecting these automotive treasures requires more than standard auto insurance—it demands specialized classic car insurance. With over 20 years of experience and 3 out of 6 of our locations being in New York, insurers like us have been at the forefront, ensuring that your prized possession receives the coverage it merits so you have the best Classic Car Insurance in Long Island.

Why Classic Car Insurance is a Must in Long Island, NY

Classic car insurance in Long Island, NY, goes beyond the ordinary, offering tailor-made policies for your vintage, antique, or collectible car. This specialized insurance is designed to address the unique needs of classic car owners, from agreed value coverage to flexible usage policies that understand cars are meant to be driven.

Classic Car Insurance Providers in Long Island, NY: A Comparative Overview

In the distinctive landscape of Long Island, NY, classic car enthusiasts seek insurance providers that not only understand their unique needs but also offer tailored solutions that enhance the value and enjoyment of their prized vehicles. While several insurers provide robust options for classic car coverage, Hotaling Insurance Services distinguishes itself, especially for high-net-worth individuals with more expensive classic cars.

Hotaling Insurance Services: A Reliable Option

Hotaling Insurance Services shines in the realm of classic car insurance, primarily due to its unparalleled ability to shop the market on behalf of its clients. This bespoke approach ensures that each client receives a policy meticulously tailored to their specific needs, preferences, and the unique value of their classic car. Hotaling’s expertise is particularly beneficial for high-net-worth individuals who require a sophisticated understanding of the nuances associated with insuring more expensive classic cars.

What Sets Hotaling Apart?

  • Market Expertise: Hotaling Insurance Services leverages its extensive experience to navigate the complex insurance market, securing policies that offer the best coverage at competitive rates.
  • Tailored Solutions: Understanding that one size does not fit all, Hotaling crafts personalized insurance solutions that reflect the individual value and use of each classic car.
  • Dedicated Service: Hotaling’s commitment to exceptional service ensures that clients receive attentive and knowledgeable support, making the insurance process seamless and efficient.

Comparing with Other Providers

While Hotaling Insurance Services caters to the distinctive needs of high-net-worth individuals and their luxury classic cars, other providers like American Collectors and J.C. Taylor also offer valuable services. These insurers provide a range of benefits, including:

  • American Collectors: Known for its flexible mileage plans, American Collectors allows classic car owners to enjoy their vehicles without worrying about exceeding mileage limits. Additionally, secure storage discounts add another layer of value for clients.
  • J.C. Taylor: This provider is recognized for its competitive premiums and wide vehicle coverage. J.C. Taylor’s policies are designed to protect everything from a single classic car to an entire collection, including motorcycles and restoration projects in progress.
  • Hagerty: Specializing in classic car insurance, Hagerty offers Guaranteed Value® coverage, ensuring owners are fully compensated in the event of a covered total loss. They also provide flexible usage policies with no fixed mileage restrictions, allowing for leisure drives and participation in car shows. Expert claims handling and support for finding rare parts or vehicles for sale further distinguish their offerings.


For classic car enthusiasts in Long Island, NY, the choice of insurance provider is crucial. While American Collectors and J.C. Taylor offer robust insurance options with their own set of advantages, Hotaling Insurance Services stands out for its unique market shopping ability and bespoke insurance solutions. Catering especially to high-net-worth individuals, Hotaling ensures that expensive classic cars receive the specialized attention and protection they deserve, making it the preferred choice for those seeking unparalleled coverage and service.


How much is classic car insurance in NY?

Classic car insurance rates in NY are generally lower than standard auto insurance, thanks to the limited use and high care classic cars receive. Rates can vary widely based on the car’s value, your driving history, and the specifics of your policy.

How old does a car have to be to be considered a classic in NY?

In New York, a car typically needs to be at least 25 years old to qualify as a classic. However, newer limited edition models and exotics might also be eligible for classic car insurance.

What’s the best insurance for a classic car?

The best classic car insurance offers a balance of competitive premiums, agreed value coverage, and flexible usage. Hotaling Insurance Services, Hagerty, American Collectors, and J.C. Taylor are among the top choices for classic car owners in Long Island, NY.

What are limitations to classic car insurance?

Classic car insurance may have limitations such as mileage caps and restrictions on daily use. Policies often require that the classic car be stored securely when not in use and that the owner has another vehicle for daily transportation.

What factors should I consider when choosing classic car insurance?

Consider the insurer’s experience with classic cars, the flexibility of their policy options, the ease of the claims process, and any additional benefits like roadside assistance or coverage for spare parts.

For more information contact any of our Agents here so we can find you the best deal for your vintage vehicle.


Get Quote Here